How do some of us stay in the Church? In grief, in sadness, with a resolve not to be shut out by those who say they are speaking in the name of the Father. We just don't believe them. The Church is not an institution; it is the people, people who are now wounded and scandalized, not only by the sexual crimes of priests, but more important, by the cover-up by those in power. In 1959 the election of Pope John XXIII was a surprise, a kind of miracle. It happened once. It could happen again. We wait, in stubborn hope, for the return of miracle. We want to make sure some of us are at home when it happens.Thanks to Andrew Sullivan for flagging it.
A blog inspired by my favorite concept from Catholic social teaching, "the preferential option for the poor," which lies at the core of two flawed institutions to which I am loyal, the Democratic Party and the Catholic Church. Opinions expressed below are those of the author and not my employer, my family or anyone else.
Tuesday, April 06, 2010
Why I Remain a Catholic
Friday, April 02, 2010
Good Friday
At noon, I went up to St. Matthews Cathedral a few blocks from my office to attend Good Friday Services. Since it is such an important day in the liturgical calendar, I feel like I should do something to get into the spirit of the day. It's a long service and does provide some spiritual sustenance as you contemplate the events of that day. Nothing says "melancholy" like a choir singing the Passion Chorale from St. Matthews Passion.
As I approached the Cathedral, I notice a crowd gathered across the street. It was on behalf of abuse victims and was a very calm, peaceful and respectful vigil. I learned later that Archbishop Weurl, who presided over the Good Friday services, stopped by the vigil and prayed with the group. Good move.
During the service, the sex abuse scandal was brought up twice. Once by a priest who was providing brief commentary on the famous "Last Words of Jesus." They are phrases that Jesus uttered on the cross before he died. One phrase was, "Father, why have you forsaken me?" The priest discussed various ways people feel forsaken by God. At the end, he mentioned people abused by priest. Importantly, he acknowledged that they were forsaken both by the priests they trusted, but hat they were also forsaken be the Church as an institution. Archbishop Wuerl also mentioned the scandal in his big homily, but he included ringing support of the Pope and was somewhat more vague on the responsibility of the Church as an institution.
So, I had to admire, to some degree, the effort to confront the issue. Then, as I drove home, I heard about homily delivered by the Pope's personal preacher in his Good Friday sermon. He compared the criticism of the Pope to anti-Semitism that culminated in the Holocaust. Big sigh! Makes my speechless. I guess I'm pleased that the Vatican had the good sense to reject the comparison. And the comments of Rev. Thomas Reese in the story about Fr. Enzler also gives some hope:
I doubt the Vatican will ever get it. The layers upon layers that provide an impenetrable bubble around the Pope deny him any sense of what's really happening. They are in total institution protection mode. But they are so misguided. Rather than protecting the institution, they are destroying it from within.But not all Catholics have leapt to the church's defense. The Rev. Thomas Reese, a scholar at Georgetown University, said the suffering-Jesus metaphor might be more fittingly applied to the victims of abuse. Reese, who spent the week analyzing the church's crisis and preparing a Good Friday message for his chapel, said he asked himself, "Who among us has experienced the betrayal, suffering and torture Jesus felt more than the victims?
Monday, March 29, 2010
Explain this
Oh yeah? Explain this.
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
Economic catastrophe
Their predictive powers are apparently undiminished as the stock market cast its judgment on health reform with a triple digit rally today.
If I were a Republican today, I would feel a cold chill. Some, like David Frum, can see the future and it's not pretty for them.
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Obama is Doomed!
These quotes are from 1982 and are about the collapsing Reagan Administration. We all know how that ended, right?The press purports to explain the problems. “Why The President’s Men Stumble,” a New York Times headline promised to explain.
Another lede concluded that the president’s “once-dazzling political momentum … has stalled.”
A noted columnist captured the pack’s mood: “the Washington press corps is suddenly in hot pursuit of ‘an administration in disarray,’ which is coming apart at the seams under … a ‘detached President.’ ”
The distinguished dean of Washington columnists opined, “it is becoming increasingly clear” that the president’s marvel “was a one-year phenomenon … what has been occurring since is an accelerating retreat … a process in which he is more spectator than leader.”
I just hope the Democrats in Congress realize that their only hope is to "PASS. THE. DAMN BILL." with apologies to Andrew Sullivan.
Sunday, March 14, 2010
Coolest Video Ever
Play it full screen with good sound to get the full effect.
Sad to think what became of these people four days later.
Friday, March 12, 2010
Mexico City
Mexico City is not at all what I expected. My image was of a hot, dirty city, teaming with people. In fact, the weather was delightful, 75 degrees, dry and crystal clear skies. The city is very clean. It is, however, teaming with people. Traffic seems heavy 24/7. I knew that was going to be a problem as we flew in. We arrived at 10 pm and, looking out the window of the plane, every highway seemed gridlocked.
Speaking of the flight, it was among the more interesting I've had. We flew over thunderstorms, which normally would have made me pretty nervous. However, the flight was perfectly smooth during this period and the flashing lights from the lightening in the clouds below was spectacular. Oddly, as we approached Mexico City, it got very bumpy under clear skies. Go figure.
Getting back to impressions of Mexico City, I was struck by how little English is displayed around the country. When I'm in China or Europe, I'm always surprised with the amount of English signage. In Mexico, there's none. Similarly, the English TV options in the hotel room are very few, far fewer than in countries much further away. I guess I admire the Mexicans' refusal to concede their culture to the Gringos from the North.
Of course, the most fascinating part of the trip was the meeting with the foreign minister. It was an important meeting dealing with some very significant issues. Unfortunately for me, most of the meeting was in Spanish. Of the approximately 20 people in the room, I was the only "mono-lingual" one there. A sad example of the failure of the American education system. Still the meeting was very successful and my team is hopeful of a continuing business relationship.
Hope I get to come back. If I do, I will spend more time investigating the rich history of Mexico, of which I only observed snatches traveling from one meeting to another.
Saturday, February 20, 2010
The Economist Gets It Wrong
It is not so much that America is ungovernable, as that Mr Obama has done a lousy job of winning over Republicans and independents to the causes he favours. If, instead of handing over health care to his party’s left wing, he had lived up to his promise to be a bipartisan president and courted conservatives by offering, say, reform of the tort system, he might have got health care through; by giving ground on nuclear power, he may now stand a chance of getting a climate bill.Wrong! Obama did offer to negotiate over tort reform and was rebuffed by the Republicans. And what of the three months was given over to Finance Chair Sen. Max Baucus to come up with a bipartisan healthcare reform bill? The strategy of the Republicans, which Sen. Grassley, minority leader of the committee, explicitly gave away, was to slow the process down and hope that lighten would strike and kill the bill. Sure enough, lighten struck in Massachusetts, but didn't quite kill it.
But for the Economist to totally absolve the Republicans for any responsibility for the gridlock in Washington is laughable. They are tacitly portrayed as this poor, ignored collection of principled conservatives. When, in fact, they are a wrecking crew, bent on the destruction of the Obama presidency.
As Obama has learned, it is very hard to find common ground with people whose fondest wish is your utter failure.
Bye, Bye Bayh
The harsh reality is that Bayh has been wrong about virtually everything. And the country suffers not because partisanship blocked action, but because the establishment consensus got too much of his agenda enacted.
Bayh supported the catastrophic invasion of Iraq. He joined the bipartisan celebration of banking deregulation. He favors more military spending. He favored tax breaks for the wealthiest Americans in an age of Gilded Age inequality. He was an advocate of corporate free trade policies that encouraged multinationals to ship jobs to a mercantilist China willing to subsidize them. He's a champion of bipartisanship -- bipartisan folly.
Even in his departing, he got it wrong. Bayh announced on CBS's Early Show that he was looking for a job in the private sector because "If I could create one job in the private sector by helping to grow a business, that would be one more than Congress has created in the last six months," This echoes the Republican assault on the recovery plan as summarized by newly elected Senate Scott Brown of Massachusetts, that the stimulus plan "didn't create one new job."
These moderates are so damned frustrating. They build their identity around the fact that the best policy lies somewhere between what Democrats want and what Republicans want. If all sides were operating good faith, this might work some of the time. But when what one party wants is for the other party to fail, the concept breaks down. Then, all the moderates do is facilitate a nihilistic approach to government by creating gridlock.
So, here we are the Republicans, who handed Obama two unfinished wars and an economy heading into another depression, have had some success painting Democrats as either incompetent failures who can't get anything done or successful socialists who are taking the country into the dictatorship of the proletariat. And the result, if achieve their goal, will be to hand the government back to them to do it all again.
Grrrr!
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Avatar
I haven't read a lot of reviews of Avatar, but, just through scanning, I have some familiarity with various issues and controversies surrounding the film. So, I'll just touch upon my view on a couple of them.
The plot, while very satisfying, is also very familiar. If you go to the effort, you can pretty much figure out everything that's going to happen in the movie after the first few minutes. My advice is, don't go to the effort. It's more fun. Let your "willing suspension of disbelief" take over.
The religious overtones of the movie are interesting. I've heard some Christians have criticized the movie as a paean to pantheism, which, in their minds, is barely one step up from atheism. I disagree. Pantheism is the believe that everything is God and God is impersonal and inscrutable. In this movie, the deity, while inscrutable, does actually seems to intervene in nature when asked to do so by the Na'Vi, much like Christians believe their God does. If anything, contrary to the Hollywood stereotype, I thought the movie showed a great respect for religion.
One aspect of the movie, however, confirms the Hollywood stereotype of the "self-hating American." The movie clearly depicts American-type characters as the bad guys. It's no mystery why this movie is so popular in China. People wait for hours there to get in to see it. It can really be seen as an allegory on Western imperialism. The top military bad guy is a caricature of the ugly American. And the civilian businessman is even worse, since he clearly knows what they are doing is wrong and is too timid to stop it. Of course, even Director James Cameron succumbs to American movie stereotypes, since the hero is also a white American male who saves the seemingly powerless natives. And, while the religion does not contradict Christianity, in my view, it does seem more Eastern than Western, which would also appeal to Chinese sensibilities.
So, the plot, while predictable, is deep enough to generate controversy and discussion. That's good. But it's not about the plot. It's about the visuals, which are stunning. You can truly understand why this movie took ten years to make. While I didn't even know it was in the making until it came out, it was worth the wait.
Monday, February 15, 2010
Sid Ceasar Does Beethoven
Monday, February 08, 2010
A Star is Born
Ted Koppel at 70
I met Ted Koppel briefly some years ago. We were both on a small plane going into Marco Island, I think. I was attending the meeting of my client, the Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS). Ted looked like he was heading for vacation. As we walked across the tarmac to the terminal, I used the opportunity to test a proposition. As PR consultant to STS, I had been telling them that a big problem they had was that nobody knew what they did. In fact, nobody knew what the word "thoracic" meant. As a result, despite their life-saving activities at the very top of the medical profession, they had little public support when they complained that payment for their services was actually declining, just when we would be needing them most. For the record, "thoracic" means chest area. They are heart and lung surgeons.
So, I thought, "I wonder if a very smart and influential guy like Ted Koppel knows what a thoracic surgeon does?" So, this exchange took place:
"Mr. Koppel, hi, I'm Bill Black. I'm a consultant for the thoracic surgeons. Do you mind if I ask you a question?"
"No, go ahead."
"Can you tell me what a thoracic surgeon does?"
"Sure. Operates on the throat."
"Sorry, no. They are heart surgeons and you've given me a great anecdote."
"Fine," Koppel says with a disgusted wave of his hand, "There's your anecdote." And he marched off, clearly pissed.
Saturday, February 06, 2010
Sublime

There are few things in life more transcendentally beautiful than the morning after a big snowstorm. And there is nothing in life that brings such beauty to your doorstep.
I experience this beauty this morning at about 7 am with vigorous trudge three blocks to Rock Creek Park. The sites and sounds were exquisite. While there was the muffling effect of snow and a low wind, there were also, surprisingly, bird calls. What hardy creatures to have made it through a night of blizzard conditions.
The snow was above my knees, which made trudging laborious. In some spots it reached my upper thigh. One neighbor was out shoveling to "get ahead of the storm." He explained that he had shoveled the night before and all his work was blown away. Of course, there's supposed to be another blast this afternoon, which will likely blown his morning's work away, as well.
I'm such a snow junky that my expectations are rarely satisfied by the actual storm. This one did it. And it ain't over yet.
Bliss.
Friday, February 05, 2010
A Beautiful Reminiscence
While my specifics are different, the mood is very familiar. It honestly brings a tear to my eye as I think about, and miss, my father. Another such memory is evoked by a poem by Robert Hayden called, Those Winter Sundays. Here's an excerpt:It is still dark when my father shakes me, cold seeming to radiate from his outside clothes. He touches my shoulder, not wanting to wake my sister in the twin bed.
"I'm awake. I'm awake," I say.
He leaves, and I go to the bathroom, where I put on layers of clothes, nothing good that will get dirty or torn. I walk downstairs and head out to his truck.
Sundays too my father got up earlyMy father died at age 52 when I was 17 years old. He remains with me in spirit. Maybe it's these kinds of memories that make me love the snow.
And put his clothes on in the blueblack cold,
Then with cracked hands that ached
From labor in the weekday weather made
Banked fires blaze. No one ever thanked him.
Bring it on!
Thursday, February 04, 2010
New Favorite Blog
I want the bullet! Bring it on! I love big snowstorms and so, apparently, do the people behind the Capitol Weather Gang. With a mega storm coming, I'm checking it almost as much as I check Talking Points Memo.
Wednesday, February 03, 2010
Reality Check
But I don't think anybody with half a brain (and maybe that excludes more people than it should) doesn't realize that the Democrats problems are overwhelmingly tied to the fact that we're in the midst of the worst recession since the end of the Second World War. Whether it's 75% of the problem or 80% or 90% I sort of go back and forth on in my mind. But clearly this is overwhelmingly the issue.That said, for the life of me, I can understand why they haven't passed the Senate bill with the reconciliation fix on healthcare.
Tuesday, February 02, 2010
Religion as a Means, not an End
I've been re-reading Screwtape and was struck by the following quote, which I think effectively describes the Christian Right in America in the last 30 years. They use their religion as a political weapon to achieve temporal ends. Bear in mind, Lewis is writing this during World War II and Screwtape is explaining how to push a mode of thought that leads to evil. If C.S. Lewis has it right, these "Christianists" are in for a surprise on judgment day. (emphasis added)
Let him begin by treating the Patriotism or the Pacifism as a part of his religion. Then let him, under the influence of partisan spirit, come to regard it as the most important part. Then quietly and gradually nurse him on to the stage at which the religion becomes merely part of the "cause", in which Christianity is valued chiefly because of the excellent arguments it can produce in favour of the British war-effort or of Pacifism. The attitude which you want to guard against is that in which temporal affairs are treated primarily as material for obedience. Once you have made the World an end, and faith a means, you have almost won your man, and it makes very little difference what kind of worldly end he is pursuing. Provided that meetings, pamphlets, policies, movements, causes, and crusades, matter more to him than prayers and sacraments and charity, he is ours—and the more "religious" (on those terms) the more securely

